Improving the R37 “Talbot” ballast hoppers (1)

Page created on 31/08/2024; updated on 03/09/2024.

“Talbot” ballast hoppers, profile view

Coupling of ballast hoppers with large side extension.

Observation

These wagons have a defect visible on the side view: the ends are more or less raised, due to their screw fixing on the central part. The correction of this problem is covered on the next page. For the moment, let’'s stay with something easier.

A load of ballast

The inside of the hoppers is detailed, with reinforcements and rivets; it’s a bit of a pity to hide this, but the planned load will be easily removable if needed.

Loading design

I want to make a load of ballast:

I’m going to use the gluing technique commonly used for ballasting tracks. I’m trying out two types of glue mix: good old vinyl wood glue on the one hand, and gesso — well, not exactly, it’s an acrylic gel sold under the Gerstaecker brand — on the other. In both cases, the dilution is approximately 50% glue and 50% household alcohol. Here are the results. When I applied the gel with a pipette (photo), it left large lumps, perhaps because I didn’t mix long enough, or because the product is a bit old.

Gluing tests

Gerstaecker acrylic gel; Atelier Belle Époque grey ballast.

After drying, the “gesso” heap remains soft, and the lumps are almost invisible, but the grains are enveloped in a very thin plastic coating that rounds them off, making their appearance unlikely. With traditional glue, the consistency is very hard, but the appearance is more satisfactory.

First tests

The main difficulty I encountered was drying: the outer layer dries very quickly, while the inside remains damp. The surface peeled off and a few air bubbles formed, just like in baking bread! The result is a heap with unrealistic puffiness.

What I’ve learnt is that you need to make a heap that’s not too thick, and that it’s necessary to let it dry as slowly as possible.

Making a mould

I have four hoppers to equip, so a mould will ensure good repeatability of manufacture.

It is made of 1.5 mm polystyrene walls to provide a degree of rigidity (1 mm walls are too flexible). The bottom, made of 3 mm extruded polystyrene (XPS), will be lost and will remain as a base under the future load.

Notches are made to hold the walls in place with elastic bands, allowing the mould to be laid flat on a support.

View of the exploded mould

The dimensions of the inside of the mould are those of the hopper, reduced by 0.5 mm. The walls fit together to facilitate assembly and dismantling of the mould.

Diagram of the mould

Making a load

The XPS base is first glued with slightly diluted wood glue, followed by a thin, evenly applied layer of ballast, with any excess removed immediately. The aim is to achieve a sufficiently solid and grippy underlay.

Ballast underlay

Once this underlay has dried, the main heap is formed by pouring the ballast into the centre of the mould using a pipette transformed into a funnel: the top of the reservoir is cut off, as is the tube, leaving only its largest diameter, in this case around 4 mm. The smaller diameter, which has been tried, doesn’t allow the ballast grains to flow out.

So, I fill the pipette’s reservoir by pinching its tube, then, by releasing the pressure, I let the ballast flow into the centre of the mould, forming a “natural” heap. If the end of the tube is close to the heap, the latter is relatively steep; if you move it away, the grains bounce back and spread out further from the centre. In this way, it’s possible to change the appearance of the heap.

Dumping the ballast

When the heap looks satisfactory (if not, it’s easy to start again by emptying the mould), it is glued with the glue + alcohol mixture, using an unmodified pipette.

From experience, it’s better to drop the glue in the middle: it will flow naturally towards the edges. How much glue should you use? It’s difficult to give a precise indication, but it should appear over the whole surface of the heap.

Gluing the heap of ballast

As already mentioned, you need to leave to dry for a long time (at least 24 hours), at a moderate temperature. Next comes the removal from the mould.

Opening the mould

Then it’s time for the finishing touches: scraping the sides to remove any grains that may have spilled over and could scratch the plastic of the hoppers. Sometimes too much is removed, and the white polystyrene base appears. If the gaps are small, you can apply a little grey paint (Humbrol acrylic slate grey No. 32 for example); otherwise, re-glue these areas, put the part back into the mould and reapply a little ballast.

Loading hoppers

For hoppers with a large side extension, an additional 3 mm layer of XPS is placed under the load to raise it. For others, this is not necessary. The weight increases from 78 g to around 94 g. This is slightly more than the NEM maximum, but this is not too much of a problem, as the axles rotate in brass bearings.

Loaded large side extension hoppers

2 × 21 m3 large side extension hoppers.

With grazing light, you can see the relief better.

Loaded small side extension hoppers

2 × 15 m3 small side extension hoppers.

Gerstaecker acrylic gel
€39,50 per litre — price 2024
at Le Géant des Beaux-Arts

ABE 695 grey HO ballast
€13,00 per litre — price 2024
at Ardennes Modélisme